Quantcast
Channel: Edutopia - Comments for When Behavior Charts Don't Work, Throw Them Out!
Browsing index pages (42 articles)

Have you tried ignoring the

Have you tried ignoring the negative behavior and reinforcing the positive behavior being displayed throughout the classroom. Sometimes students like the attention they receive. Just a suggestion. Hope...

View Article


I haven't had much luck with

I haven't had much luck with behavior charts either. The students eventually start asking if they can move down another student on the chart. Some do take it seriously and if I actually followed...

View Article


I really enjoyed the article.

I really enjoyed the article. I have never personally been a fan of behavior charts for all of the reasons you stated, and I think that you have shared a fantastic alternative. I think that even for as...

View Article

I think that is such an

I think that is such an awesome idea cmarie, to have a class meeting at the end of the day. I think its another way of helping students focus on important and positive things as well as really build a...

View Article

I am a special ed behavior

I am a special ed behavior aid and I am mandated by the school pysch and classroom teacher to use a behavior chart. My current student loathes it and it is pretty vague. I love that you suggested the...

View Article


I jus finished my 1st year

I jus finished my 1st year teaching a 2nd grade group. It was a very challenging group! Some days were very good, some others very bad. I was ending my day thinking "Why?, What am I doing wrong? My...

View Article

you have my permission to

you have my permission to post my comments

View Article

@Kmcrawford - I would like to

@Kmcrawford - I would like to ask permission to use your post as a discussion item for a teacher PD in CHAMPS. Please contact me directly at rhohls@vcoe.org. Thanks so much!

View Article


4th grade - I've been using

4th grade - I've been using Class Dojo for the past few years. My class and I decide what behaviors are worthy of giving points for and what are worthy of taking them away. I also allow them to spend...

View Article


What are some of the most

What are some of the most recommended behavior charts/ systems? I am sure they will be different depending on the grade in school. I am interested to see the differences between a Kindergarten behavior...

View Article

Perhaps a behavior chart

Perhaps a behavior chart would be more effective if it focused on positive behavior rather than negative. If everyone else in the class is moving upwards towards the reward section and the problem...

View Article

My first year teaching was in

My first year teaching was in a 3-6th mixed grades community day school that used a punitive behavior chart where students began each period with 4 points and could lose points for behaviors. The kids...

View Article

Very well said. Thank you so

Very well said. Thank you so much for writing this...I work at a place where shame and calling young people "manipulative and unmotivated" occurs consistently and on a daily basis. That's why I like...

View Article


LOVE Dr. Greene' s work. His

LOVE Dr. Greene' s work. His books and FREE materials on his website, livesinbalance.com, not to mention his YouTube videos, are all amazing! I was a teacher for over 30 years until I recently accepted...

View Article

In my experience working with

In my experience working with children and their teachers, behavior charts work great...until they don't. They work when the child has the skills to deal with the who, what, where. While the criteria...

View Article


I agree that it is important

I agree that it is important to teach students in those teachable moments. This is more likely to provide students with tools and experiences to learn the appropriate replacement behavior. Expectations...

View Article

I agree with actually

Hello vlevans3,I agree with actually teaching and guiding kids. This is especially true when establishing and maintaining expectations in our classrooms. In addition to teaching curriculum, we must...

View Article


I agree with you. It is

Hey Rebekah,I agree with you. It is important for general education to know also how to handle students who are not behaving appropriately. It is extremely important for them to have strategies on...

View Article

Thank you for the post, I

Thank you for the post, I agree that showing student's that are on the negative path doesn't do much for their confidence to put themselves on the positive path. Positive reinforcement goes a long way...

View Article

Great post. So glad to hear

Great post. So glad to hear you moved from a punishing system (the dreaded behavior chart) to a positive system - 5 positively stated expectations and the Think Letter. This change will change the...

View Article
Browsing index pages (42 articles)


Latest Images